Kindle vs iSlate – Review of Apple iSlate patent

Kindle vs iSlate seems imminent – It turns out that Apple owns the iSlate.com domain name and have booked a conference venue for January 26th.

Let’s consider Kindle vs iSlate, review the latest iSlate developments, and see what impact the iSlate might have on the Kindle.

Kindle Vs iSlate – Apple owns iSlate.com domain name

MacRumors did some sleuthing today and found out that before the ownership of iSlate.com was hidden behind a shield of privacy it was registered to Apple Inc. using its Cupertino address. 

While there are some harmless possibilities -

  1. Apple is just hoarding up domain names people might use to get to Apple’s Tablet. 
  2. That it is one of the last few contenders and we might see iTablet be the actual name. 

There are also some signs that iSlate is indeed the name of the Apple Tablet -

  1. Bill Keller had referred to the Apple Tablet in October as the Apple Slate
  2. iSlate is more in the vein of the iPhone and the iPod.  
  3. No Tablet has been a success and it would make sense to start off with a new name – create the perception that this is a revolutionary new product and not just a new form of a tablet.

Is the iSlate set to debut in January?

The Financial Times has the scoop on a potential Apple iSlate release announcement in January -

The company has rented a stage at the Yerba Buena Center for the Arts in San Francisco for several days in late January, according to people familiar with the plans.

Piper Jaffray analyst Gene Munster thinks it’s the iSlate -

“We believe there is a 75 per cent likelihood that Apple will have an event in January and a 50 per cent chance that it will be held to launch the Apple Tablet,”

“If Apple announced the Tablet in January, it would likely ship later in the March quarter.”

The number of rumors and news items and the amount of solid facts is higher than at any other point. January is probably it for an iSlate formal announcement.

The recent updates of Apple’s computer lines, not to mention the updates of the iPhone and iPod in the 2nd half of 2010, suggest the January 26th event will be all about the Apple iSlate.

Kindle vs iSlate – Review of iSlate’s multi-touch tactile keyboard

Apple Insider has the scoop on a new patent filed this week that suggests the iSlate will use a dynamic surface that gives users tactile feedback as they type.

Using an “articulating frame,” the surface of such a device would create physical bumps or dots for the user to feel when it is in keyboard mode.

It is detailed in an application entitled “Keystroke Tactility Arrangement on a Smooth Touch Surface.”

Quite frankly, the idea is brilliant -

  1. When sliding gestures or clicks are detected then the surface behaves like a smooth touchscreen. 
  2. When you place fingers on the home row of the keyboard it changes i.e. the physical frame morphs into typing mode and gives you tactile feedback.

It makes me wonder whether the keyboard might be on the back of the device in addition to the screen.

Apple Insider point out that related patents were also filed in 2007 and earlier in the year.

The latter patent is very interesting as it was a surface that could detect 10 individual fingers while ignoring your palms resting on the screen. Combine that with the tactile feedback and you have an actual ‘feelable’ keyboard built into the touch screen.

 iSlate 7″ and iSlate 10″ – Taking on both Kindle and Kindle DX

UK gadget website T3 think that Apple is buying up 7″ touchscreens to the point that it’s almost impossible to get any. Various other sites (including Boy Genius Report) have had sources hint that there will be two models of the Apple iSlate -

  1. A 7″ screen model which compares well with most eReaders i.e. the Kindle, the Nook, etc. 
  2. A 10″ screen model which compares with the Kindle DX’s 9.7″ screen.

This makes a lot of sense because these sizes fit in very well with users wanting various combinations of portability and screen size. These would also fill the void between the iPhone and the MacBook.

It does seem strange that the iSlate would debut with two sizes – Would’ve thought Apple would start with one size and then expand later.

Kindle vs iSlate – How much of a threat is the iSlate?

We keep coming back to this question and it’s best to think of people who want an ebook reader as two groups -

  1. People who want a dedicated ebook reader. The Kindle, or a similar dedicated eReader, will always be the first choice for this group.
  2. People who want to be able to read an occasional book on their device. The iSlate fits in perfectly for these people.

Reading Devices are going to be a huge market and there will be more than enough space for both the Kindle and the iSlate. Kindle vs iSlate decisions come down to what your primary purpose for the device is and they aren’t really competing against each other.

Any Kindle vs iSlate review or comparison ought to start off with the disclaimer that these are entirely different devices targeted at different purposes.

6 Responses

  1. Good logic here. Well written. At least we can be sure that, when the iSlate hits the marketplace, it won’t get nook’d in the manner of B&N’s device, that e-reader that went to market as an unfinished and very much flawed product.

  2. Assuming the iSlate is an LCD screen, I think it will have the same problem as reading books on current 10″ netbooks — it’s just not as comfortable on the eyes and batteries to read books on that kind of screen.

  3. Dont think batteries will be a problem since its size
    allow more space for larger ones. What bugs me is
    that you need an external mouse and keyboard even
    though you can use the screen but with reduced area.
    The name also is not so good, i would have chosen
    something more intuitive : like itop or iscreen but not
    islate. Sounds like islave.

  4. It is islate because people used to write on slates, or tablets, and repeatedly used the same slate for multiple documents/pages. Granted they had to wipe the slate clean to have a new page but seems to make the name islate very intuitive.

  5. For reading novels, I prefer the kinds that kill trees however, having a device with an e-book function would be nice. My interest in an e-reading device is based on business needs.

    From a potential user’s perspective, I want to be able to read PDF files, page by page as if they were printed on sheets of 8X11 paper (with decent font sizes) and I want to be able to carry the content of large PDF files on a light-weight device without a lot of hassle. Graphs and charts should maintain their format as in the PDF files. Searchability would be essential. Storage space, battery life are important features as well. Ability to upload files with USB sticks is essential.

    I am tired of trying to read large documents on my laptop. I am going blind from reading texts and scrolling every couple of paragraphs and it doesn’t seem like an 8X11 electronic device for reading would be too much to ask for. If such a iSlate comes to market, it will immediately dominate the e-book marketplace if the price is right.

  6. …think of the educational possibilities with an apple e-reader!
    +updated text books
    +all textbooks in one spot (lightweight)
    +ability to keep all text books for future reference
    +did i say lightweight!
    +sharing information-if you can play air hockey with 2 iphones, think of how you could share notes and thoughts with two apple “i-slates”
    I wish I was in school just to use the tech today~my kids are lucky…sure hope apple hears this!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 9,810 other followers