Kindle Vs Kindle for PC Vs Kindle for iPhone becomes a really interesting choice if you’re not sure you want to spend $259 on a dedicated eReader like Kindle 2.
Here’s a video contrasting the three options –
Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of each –
Where does the Kindle shine?
The Kindle does great at reading – exactly what you’d expect in an eReader. It also has a lot of benefits that the PC and iPhone offerings don’t i.e. Read To Me, Free Internet Access, etc.
Kindle – Pros
- The Screen is great for reading and works in all lighting conditions.
- The Screen does not hurt your eyes.
- There are zero distractions.
- In-built dictionary and Search.
- Free Wikipedia access and Free Internet access for reference.
- Good sized screen i.e. 6″.
Kindle – Cons
- You have to buy a Kindle for $259.
- No Color.
- No Touch.
- Not as compact as an iPhone.
- Screen isn’t as big as a laptop or PC.
Please check my Kindle 2 Review if you’re thinking of getting a Kindle.
Where does Kindle for PC shine?
Kindle for PC lets you read all your Kindle Books (or any book in the Kindle Store) on any PC, anywhere in the world.
Kindle for PC – Pros
- Very, very simple and easy to use.
- It’s free.
- Color (and on Windows 7 multi-touch).
- Lots of font sizes and lots of options for number of words per line.
- Works on almost every netbook and PC (Kindle for Mac is slated for release in a few months).
- Works on Windows XP, Vista and Windows 7.
- Windows 7 optimized i.e. multi-touch etc.
- Screen is as big as your monitor.
- Lets you shop the Kindle Store and buy books. Though the ‘Shop in Kindle Store’ button doesn’t seem to be working for me.
Kindle for PC – Cons
- Portability is limited to portability of your PC (none) or Laptop (good) or Netbook (much better than a PC).
- The Screen hurts your eyes – although if you disagree feel free to leave a comment.
- For the moment you can’t add notes and highlights.
- No Text To Speech.
- It’s more of an add-on than an independent offering.
Check my detailed review of Kindle for PC if you want more details.
Kindle for iPhone
Kindle for iPhone recently added support for notes and highlights and made it a better product.
Kindle for iPhone – Pros
- You have your phone with you nearly all the time.
- Fits in your pocket.
- Color and Multi-touch.
- Bright LCD screen for reading without light at night.
- Sepia theme/color setting is great.
- 5 Font Sizes and 3 text color settings.
Kindle for iPhone – Cons
- Doesn’t work well in bright light (sunshine).
- Screen is too small.
- Screen hurts your eyes – again, leave your comments if you feel compelled to disagree.
- Lots of distractions.
- Battery life doesn’t compare with the Kindle.
Check my iPhone Reading App Reviews for more on iPhone reading.
The big takeaway after contrasting the three is –
Amazon is creating Kindle for PC and Kindle for iPhone as Starting Points (Add-On Services for Owners)
Amazon is making it a point to make the Kindle the focal point and create Kindle for PC and Kindle for iPhone as starting points from which you can graduate to buying a Kindle.
For Kindle owners, they become valuable add-ons. Think of the features –
- The ability to sync your book location across the devices.
- The ability to make notes and highlights on the Kindle and the iPhone (and soon on the PC).
- Access notes and bookmarks across devices.
- Buy books and access your books from all three.
These features combine to create a very compelling overall offering.
How do Kindle for PC and Kindle for iPhone rate as independent products?
By themselves, both Kindle for PC and Kindle for iPhone are starting points – they are good enough for reading. As you begin to read more you’ll probably want a Kindle.
There are going to be people who curse me for writing that a PC or an iPhone can not be as good for reading as a Kindle.
However, ‘good enough’ is not the same as ‘great’.
- Reading on the Kindle is 8.5 stars (8.75 stars if you’re generous).
- Reading using Kindle for iPhone is 7 stars – Amazon intentionally leave a few features out to not make it too good. There are other apps that hit 7.5 despite the eye-strain and small screen size.
- Reading using Kindle for PC is perhaps 7 to 7.5 – haven’t done enough of it to say for sure. Again, you get the feeling Amazon left out some features to ensure it’s a stepping stone to the Kindle and not a substitute.
If you love to read and can afford it, get a Kindle. If $259 is out of your reach, get Kindle for PC or Kindle for iPhone.
Where does that leave us?
- Well, lots of people will download and read on one or both of Kindle for PC and Kindle for iPhone.
- Some of them, especially the ones who read a lot, will end up deciding to buy a Kindle.
- The books they’ve bought already and the use of a Kindle offering ties them to Amazon.
- Even people who don’t buy a Kindle will associate ‘Kindle’ with ebooks and reading.
Kindle for PC and Kindle for iPhone are great for Amazon
Amazon is already doing great with eReaders.
- If the skeptics are right and eReaders disappear then Amazon still owns the main reading channels and can sell ebooks.
- If the skeptics are wrong, then Amazon owns the main channel i.e. eReaders and also owns the other important channels (PCs, netbooks, iPhones).
Barnes and Noble have become a real threat to Amazon (something Sony never was). Kindle for PC is a necessary measure – expect a few more Kindle features and improvements before Christmas.
As far as Kindle Vs Kindle for PC Vs Kindle for iPhone – all of them are simple to use and great products. The range of books in the Kindle Store and the low prices make each a compelling option.
If you read a book a week (or more), the Kindle is worth the $259. If you read just one book a month, get Kindle for PC and Kindle for iPhone and enjoy the Kindle store.